under the spreading chestnut tree...i sold you and you sold me.
About this Entry
Posted by: GrassyNollie

Visit GrassyNollie's Xanga Site

Original: 4/2/2008 4:17 PM
Views: 82
Comments: 5
eProps: 6

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site

Who recommended?

Who gave the eProps?
2 eProps!2 eProps! 2 eProps from:
penguin18
roy_easton
HazelEyedBandid


Wednesday, April 02, 2008

 RESPONSE TO ANY (HOWEVER, ONE IN PARTICULAR) WHITE MALE WHO QUESTIONED THE OFFENSIVENESS OF THE "MR. NDSU BLACKFACE" INCIDENT:

as a heterosexual, white male, you wouldn't find it offensive--would you? you aren't the one that gets to decide whether or not this is offensive. you can have your opinion about it, but you owe it to those whose situation you do not understand, and will NEVER understand, to respect their right to be offended. it wasn't blackface in the sense that the guy didn't have white painted lips, but it was clearly a gesture at blackface in the very least, and is therefore associated with the historical connotations of blackface, i.e. an overtly racist act meant to make fun of african americans in a time when they were even moreso oppressed than they are now.

it is NOT the same thing as when dave chappelle puts on white makeup, it's not the same as when men dress as women, it's not even the same as when griffin darkened himself to research Black Like Me. it's all about the historical context and--to a lesser extent--the intention of the act. it's also a matter of being inappropriate for the medium in which it was presented: at a sorority-run fundraiser. it wasn't sarah silverman dressing in blackface on comedy central, it was a student expecting to impress judges at a male university pagent. if i had friends who previewed their mr. ndsu show for me, and it was like this, i would’ve told them that not only was it not clever or funny, but would get them in major trouble, and would likely alienate and offend people. somehow, out of all the people who knew about this skit, not one of them knew not to do it, and that is what is scary.

that said, i truly don't think that this guy meant to cause the kind of trouble that he did for the school, or be racist in any way, but you have to be pretty out of the loop to know how inappropriate painting your face dark is in this context and this country.


 Posted 4/2/2008 4:17 PM - 82 Views - 6 eProps - 5 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

5 Comments

Visit penguin18's Xanga Site!
Great post.
Posted 4/2/2008 5:01 PM by penguin18 - reply

Visit roy_easton's Xanga Site!
Yes, I agree, great post. I would like to comment on a couple of things. The first is simply a correction: John Howard Griffin wrote Black Like Me--a truly remarkable book that everyone should read. And for the more eager reader, Carl Rowan's South of Freedom is also exceptional; it was written about ten years prior to Griffin's book and is the actual account of a black journalist from Minneapolis who "tours" the south in order to write an extended column on the social conditions of the south (interesting side note: the most racist place he visited? Washington DC--the capital of the northern states...).

My other comment has to do with parody in our contemporary culture. We see it all the time, as noted above in your post. As a result, the history of black-face gets lost on modern (white) people. This history is often never taught or understood. People should recognize it as a bad thing, but they get little support from the 21st century media. They see others do it, and then ask why can't I? Insert the need for a history lesson here. Where I agree Chappelle and Silverman (maybe Silverman) have a higher agenda (other than comedy), I also recognize the fact that this agenda gets lost and needs to be emphasized more often. After all, is this not one of the main reasons behind Dave's departure? I tend to like Silverman, but I also think she rides a very thin line. If we are going to see change with this issue, it needs to start with education, both in the schools and in the media.

I do not excuse the ignorant, but what are we doing to prevent this?

One last comment, sorry. It is interesting to note that with all the attention this Mr. NDSU is getting across the country, no one seems to mention that two men dressed as cowboys were simulating gay sex in the background, at least according to the initial report I read on the wire.
Posted 4/3/2008 10:30 AM by roy_easton - reply

Visit GrassyNollie's Xanga Site!
woops...i wrote higgins? woops woops woops. my bad, sorry. i read that book in fifth grade, but it could use a re-reading in my adulthood.
Posted 4/3/2008 6:03 PM by GrassyNollie - reply

Visit GrassyNollie's Xanga Site!
oh, and most every report i read did mention the homophobic nature of the skit, but certainly most of the debate is over the blackface aspect. it seems to me that this is just because the man who painted himself touched on such a specific act so closely linked w/ racism. maybe i'm giving them too much credit...
Posted 4/3/2008 6:07 PM by GrassyNollie - reply

Visit HazelEyedBandid's Xanga Site!
I totally agree.. if your not being talked about how do you know how it truly feels?!
Posted 4/10/2008 1:54 PM by HazelEyedBandid - reply


Choose Identity
(?)
 
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to GrassyNollie's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in GrassyNollie's local time zone:
GMT -06:00 (Central Standard - US, Canada)
//Get this code at http://help.xanga.com/replacelinks.htm Site Meter I adopted a cute lil' pikachu fetus from Fetusmart! Hooray fetus! The current mood of GrassyNollie at www.imood.com
adopt your own virtual pet!